Testfall · A relied-on figure with no named document, against a passage the copy omits
figure-without-document
- Grupp
- regression-unsupported-claim · Gruppversion 2
- Testsvit
- Testsvit controlled-regression, version 1
- Evidensklass
- REGRESSION
The engine reports a charge set from a figure that names no document when a supplied rule makes that unsupported, and reports nothing when the copy does not carry the passage that would decide it.
Testdokumenten, reglerna och facit visas på engelska, det språk de skrevs på.
Vad det här testfallet ändrar
- Faktor
- the passage the rule would be applied to
- Nivå
- present and unsourced
- Jämförs med
- basis-withheldÄndringen ska ändra svaret. Ett textställe i dokumentet skiljer sig mellan de två.
The levy is set from a tonnage the entry does not source.
Dokumentet motorn fick
Exakt den text motorn fick, rad för rad.
- Levy entry LV-440
- Ship calling
- The cargo ship Marta Holm called at the south quay.
- Basis of the charge
- The levy was set from the ship's gross tonnage of 1,840.
- Levy result
- The harbour levy is recorded as payable in full.
Reglerna motorn fick
Varje regel visas under en neutral beteckning i stället för sitt interna namn.
Regel A
The document a charged figure was read from
Källa: Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1
In a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from. A figure whose document is not named gives the charge no support. The duty rests on the author of the record.
Facit
Skrevs ner innan motorn kördes. unsourced-figure-truth
The charge is set from a stated figure and the entry names no document for it.
Facit är uttömmande: varje fynd som inte står som förväntat räknas som fel.
Förväntade fynd
- BristUtelämnandeFynd charged-figure-without-document
The entry sets the levy from a figure and names no document it was read from.
- Ska förankras i
The levy was set from the ship's gross tonnage of 1,840.
- Ska hänvisa till
- Regel A
- Kontrolleras i
- granskarens eget utfall, den levererade rapporten
Förbjudna fynd
Fel svar, nedskrivna i förväg.
- StyrkaFynd unsourced-figure-praised
Crediting the figure for naming its document when it names none.
- Ska förankras i
The levy was set from the ship's gross tonnage of 1,840.
- Ska hänvisa till
- Regel A
- Kontrolleras i
- granskarens eget utfall, den levererade rapporten
Vad den blinda läsaren svarade
En AI-läsare fick det här dokumentet och dess regler, men inte facit, och svarade på egen hand. Jämför svaret med facit ovan.
- Överens med facitClaude, 5 oktober 2026Punkt i läsarens underlag item-02
- BristUtelämnandeRegel A
Ska förankras i
The levy was set from the ship's gross tonnage of 1,840.
- Överens med facitGemini, 5 oktober 2026Punkt i läsarens underlag item-02
- BristUtelämnandeRegel A
Ska förankras i
The levy was set from the ship's gross tonnage of 1,840.
Kritisk granskning av facit
En AI-modellsession försökte hitta fel i det här facit enligt ett publicerat protokoll: är varje väntat fynd verkligen ett brott mot regeln, är varje felfritt fall verkligen felfritt, prövar fallet det det säger sig pröva, och skulle ett lika riktigt svar som pekar på ett annat ställe räknas som fel. Den tittade inte på motorns resultat först. Varje invändning visas med hur den avgjordes. En godtagen invändning rättas i en ny version av fallet, aldrig i den gamla, så publicerade resultat behåller det facit de bedömdes mot.
Ingen kritisk granskning av det här facit finns registrerad.
Testets instruktion till granskaren
Testkonfigurationen gav AI-granskaren den här instruktionen vid sidan av reglerna. Det är testets egen instruktion. Produktionens systemprompt visas inte.
You read one document and apply only the rules supplied to you in the legal framework, exactly as each rule is written. Report every place where the document does not meet a supplied rule, and apply what a supplied rule says about how a record that meets it is to be recorded. Quote each passage exactly as it appears. Do not apply a rule that was not supplied, and do not rely on any knowledge of a legal system.Vem som skrev och läste det här testfallet
En AI-modellsession skrev de här testfallen, och en annan AI-modellsession läste dem blint utan att se facit. Ingen människa har granskat dem.
- Skrevs
- , registrerat som Claude Project thread session for #3075
- Modellfamilj som skrev det
- Claude
- Varför det skrevs
- Authored for #2323 as new REGRESSION material in the outcome shapes of the controlled-pilot suite, sharing none of its text. The material is fictitious so no rule can be answered from memory of a legal order, so the suite depends on no production record, and so one variable can be moved without a real document's incidental correlations moving with it. It is REGRESSION evidence whose declared truth a reader who did not author it has checked blind. Version 2 corrects version 1 for #3075: an adversarial critique showed that an omission anchored on the sentence setting the levy, as correct as the key's, was scored as a miss. Version 2 states the figure and the charge set from it as one sentence.
Granskning
Skrivna av en AI-modellsession: Claude.
Blind läsning, Claude, 5 oktober 2026: 2 av 2 överens
registrerat som Claude Project thread subagent for #3075 (Claude Opus 5.5), blind read
Ingen oenighet med facit.
Se vad den blinda läsaren svarade i varje testfallBlind läsning, Gemini, 5 oktober 2026: 2 av 2 överens
registrerat som gemini-2.5-pro (Vertex europe-west1), blind read
Ingen oenighet med facit.
Se vad den blinda läsaren svarade i varje testfall
AI-modeller skrev och granskade de här testfallen, som anges ovan. Ingen människa har granskat dem. Varje oenighet mellan en AI-granskare och facit publiceras här.
Fingeravtryck
SHA-256-hashvärden som en läsare kan jämföra med en publicerad körnings rapport.
- Dokument
- f899d21aad385570091cdd0c546c16e4900b804ab86a7b49f106ea35b7a7b92c
- Dokumentmall
- 1e2f522c3a8a20b3c8c8b90f93181b5e09a2fc9c59e8813d37cb50f566d3dd3f
- Regel A
- fa3928d90b453dd2d705189e5d07ab64c11337803e039b0f60e0ab3268b5a7d6
Resultat i publicerade körningar
Senaste först. Varje kolumn är en körning av det här testfallet.
Mätkörning med releasedesignen, ingen release,
Det här testfallet i varje körning av omgången. Testfall Körning 1 Körning 2 Körning 3 Körning 4 Körning 5 Bedömt mot version 1Endast granskaren2 olika uppsättningar fynd över körningarna - charged-figure-without-document Brist: hittad, på rätt textställe och med rätt regel
Inga fynd utöver facit
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
- charged-figure-without-document Brist: hittad, på rätt textställe och med rätt regel
Inga fynd utöver facit
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
- charged-figure-without-document Brist: hittad, på rätt textställe och med rätt regel
Inga fynd utöver facit
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
- charged-figure-without-document Brist: inte hittad, men regeln nämndes i ett annat fynd
1 oväntad brist
- Hänvisade till: Regel A
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
- charged-figure-without-document Brist: hittad, på rätt textställe och med rätt regel
Inga fynd utöver facit
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
Vad varierade mellan körningarna
Fynd som vissa körningar gav och andra inte. Varje länk går till motorns svar i den körningen.
Endast granskaren
- Förväntat fynd charged-figure-without-document: Brist, hittad, på rätt textställe och med rätt regel I: Körning 1, Körning 2, Körning 3, Körning 5
- Förväntat fynd charged-figure-without-document: Brist, inte hittad, men regeln nämndes i ett annat fynd I: Körning 4
- Oväntad brist. Hänvisade till: Regel A. På rad 4 i dokumentet I: Körning 4
Se motorns egna svar
Det här är motorns egna svar, på den engelska den skrev dem, visade precis som de kom tillbaka och oredigerade. Upprepningarna står sida vid sida, så att du själv kan se hur formuleringarna varierar även när det poängsatta resultatet är detsamma.
System- och användarprompterna som motorn fick publiceras inte: de hör till produkten, inte till testet. Dokumentet, reglerna och instruktionen som testet gav visas ovan.
Körning 1
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The document is a record regarding levy entry LV-440 for the ship Marta Holm. Under 'Basis of the charge', it states: 'The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.' and 'The levy was set from that tonnage.' 2. TRACE: Tracing the figure (1,840 gross tonnage) used to set the levy reveals that no document or source from which this figure was read is identified or cited in the record. 3. EVALUATE: According to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (L1), in a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from. The document fails to name the source document for the figure. 4. SYNTHESIZE: Formulate a single flaw for the omission of the source document reference under the heading 'Basis of the charge', classified under STATED_CLAIM.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Missing source documentation
- Förklaring
- The record sets a levy charge from a figure (gross tonnage of 1,840) but omits the name of the document from which the figure was read, in violation of Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
- Utelämnande
- Ja · ett påstående saknar det som krävs av det
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Körning 2
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The document is a record of levy entry LV-440 regarding the cargo ship Marta Holm calling at the south quay. Under the heading 'Basis of the charge', it states: 'The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.' and 'The levy was set from that tonnage.' Under 'Levy result', it states: 'The harbour levy is recorded as payable in full.' 2. TRACE: Tracing the figure of 1,840 gross tonnage used to set the levy reveals that no source document or origin document is named in the text for this figure. 3. EVALUATE: According to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (L1), in a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from, placing the duty on the author of the record. The record provides the figure 1,840 and sets the levy from it, but fails to name the document the figure was read from. 4. SYNTHESIZE: This constitutes an omission under the stated claim regarding the tonnage figure used to set the levy charge.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Omission of source document
- Förklaring
- The record sets a levy charge based on a figure of 1,840 gross tonnage but fails to name the document from which that figure was read, as required by Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
- Utelämnande
- Ja · ett påstående saknar det som krävs av det
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Körning 3
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The document is a record of levy entry LV-440 for the cargo ship Marta Holm calling at the south quay. Under 'Basis of the charge', it states: 'The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.' and 'The levy was set from that tonnage.' Under 'Levy result', it states: 'The harbour levy is recorded as payable in full.' 2. TRACE: The figure of 1,840 gross tonnage is stated without any reference to the source document from which it was obtained or read. 3. EVALUATE: According to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (Law L1), 'In a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from. A figure whose document is not named gives the charge no support. The duty rests on the author of the record.' The record sets a charge from the figure of 1,840 gross tonnage, but fails to identify or name the document from which this figure was read. 4. SYNTHESIZE: This constitutes an omission on a stated claim (omission_evidence: STATED_CLAIM) under the heading 'Basis of the charge'. The author of the record has violated Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Omission of source document
- Förklaring
- The record sets a levy from a gross tonnage figure of 1,840 without naming the document from which the figure was read, contrary to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
Sida: Throughout - Utelämnande
- Ja · ett påstående saknar det som krävs av det
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Körning 4
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: Identified causal and factual claims in the record: 'The cargo ship Marta Holm called at the south quay.', 'The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.', 'The levy was set from that tonnage.', and 'The harbour levy is recorded as payable in full.' 2. TRACE: Traced the basis of the charge to the figure of 1,840 gross tonnage and the setting of the levy from that figure. No source document is cited anywhere in the record for this figure. 3. EVALUATE: Evaluated against Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (L1), which mandates that in a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from. The record fails to state the document from which the gross tonnage figure was read. 4. SYNTHESIZE: Formulated the finding as an omission of a required element on a stated claim (STATED_CLAIM) under the heading 'Basis of the charge'.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Omission of source document
- Förklaring
- The record sets a levy charge from a gross tonnage figure without naming the document from which the figure was read, contrary to the mandatory requirement in Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1.
- Citat
The levy was set from that tonnage.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
- Utelämnande
- Ja · ett påstående saknar det som krävs av det
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Körning 5
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The document is a record of 'Levy entry LV-440' regarding the ship 'Marta Holm'. Under the heading 'Basis of the charge', it states: 'The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.' and 'The levy was set from that tonnage.' Under 'Levy result', it records the harbour levy as payable in full. 2. TRACE: Tracing the figure of 1,840 gross tonnage back through the document reveals no mention of any source document, certificate, or registry from which this figure was obtained or read. 3. EVALUATE: According to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (id: L1), in a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from. A figure whose document is not named gives the charge no support, and the duty rests on the author of the record. The document sets a levy from the gross tonnage figure of 1,840 but fails to name the document the figure was read from. 4. SYNTHESIZE: This constitutes an omission with stated claim evidence (the figure and levy basis are stated, but the mandatory source document is omitted).
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Missing source document
- Förklaring
- The record sets a levy charge based on a gross tonnage figure of 1,840 without naming the document from which the figure was read, contrary to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
- Utelämnande
- Ja · ett påstående saknar det som krävs av det
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Schemalagd nattkörning,
Det här testfallet i varje körning av omgången. Testfall Körning 1 Bedömt mot version 1Endast granskaren - charged-figure-without-document Brist: hittad, på rätt textställe och med rätt regel
Inga fynd utöver facit
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
Se motorns egna svar
Det här är motorns egna svar, på den engelska den skrev dem, visade precis som de kom tillbaka och oredigerade. Upprepningarna står sida vid sida, så att du själv kan se hur formuleringarna varierar även när det poängsatta resultatet är detsamma.
System- och användarprompterna som motorn fick publiceras inte: de hör till produkten, inte till testet. Dokumentet, reglerna och instruktionen som testet gav visas ovan.
Körning 1
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The document is a record containing a levy entry (LV-440) for the ship Marta Holm calling at south quay. Under 'Basis of the charge', the document states: 'The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.' and 'The levy was set from that tonnage.' Under 'Levy result', the levy is recorded as payable in full. 2. TRACE: Tracing the figure '1,840' and the setting of the levy from that tonnage reveals that no source document is cited or named anywhere in the record. 3. EVALUATE: According to the binding law (Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1; id='L1'), in a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from. Because the author of the record set the levy from the gross tonnage figure of 1,840 without naming the document from which that figure was read, the record fails to comply with the statutory requirement. 4. SYNTHESIZE: This constitutes an omission on a stated claim (is_omission=true, omission_evidence='STATED_CLAIM'). No other legal rules or guidelines are provided, and no norm conflicts or compliant strengths under the provided framework exist.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Omission of source document
- Förklaring
- The levy entry sets a charge from a figure (gross tonnage of 1,840) but fails to name the document the figure was read from, contrary to the mandatory requirement that every levy entry setting a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
- Utelämnande
- Ja · ett påstående saknar det som krävs av det
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Schemalagd nattkörning,
Det här testfallet i varje körning av omgången. Testfall Körning 1 Bedömt mot version 1Endast granskaren - charged-figure-without-document Brist: hittad, på rätt textställe och med rätt regel
Inga fynd utöver facit
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
Se motorns egna svar
Det här är motorns egna svar, på den engelska den skrev dem, visade precis som de kom tillbaka och oredigerade. Upprepningarna står sida vid sida, så att du själv kan se hur formuleringarna varierar även när det poängsatta resultatet är detsamma.
System- och användarprompterna som motorn fick publiceras inte: de hör till produkten, inte till testet. Dokumentet, reglerna och instruktionen som testet gav visas ovan.
Körning 1
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The document contains a record of a levy entry (LV-440) for the ship Marta Holm. Under 'Basis of the charge', it states: 'The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.' and 'The levy was set from that tonnage.' 2. TRACE: The tonnage figure (1,840) is stated directly as the basis for setting the levy, but no source document or origin for where this figure was read from is identified in the text. 3. EVALUATE: According to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (L1), every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from. Without naming the source document, the figure gives the charge no support. 4. SYNTHESIZE: The record violates L1 because it records a figure (1,840 gross tonnage) used to set a levy charge without naming the source document from which the figure was obtained. This is an omission on a stated claim (STATED_CLAIM).
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Missing source documentation
- Förklaring
- The record sets a levy charge from a gross tonnage figure of 1,840 without naming the document from which the figure was read, contrary to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
- Utelämnande
- Ja · ett påstående saknar det som krävs av det
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Körning efter en ändring i motorn,
Det här testfallet i varje körning av omgången. Testfall Körning 1 Körning 2 Körning 3 Bedömt mot version 1Endast granskarenSamma fynd i varje körning - charged-figure-without-document Brist: hittad, på rätt textställe och med rätt regel
Inga fynd utöver facit
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
- charged-figure-without-document Brist: hittad, på rätt textställe och med rätt regel
Inga fynd utöver facit
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
- charged-figure-without-document Brist: hittad, på rätt textställe och med rätt regel
Inga fynd utöver facit
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
Se motorns egna svar
Det här är motorns egna svar, på den engelska den skrev dem, visade precis som de kom tillbaka och oredigerade. Upprepningarna står sida vid sida, så att du själv kan se hur formuleringarna varierar även när det poängsatta resultatet är detsamma.
System- och användarprompterna som motorn fick publiceras inte: de hör till produkten, inte till testet. Dokumentet, reglerna och instruktionen som testet gav visas ovan.
Körning 1
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: Scan the record for all causal claims, figures, and charge determinations. Under the heading 'Basis of the charge', the text states: 'The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.' and 'The levy was set from that tonnage.' Under 'Levy result', it states: 'The harbour levy is recorded as payable in full.' 2. TRACE: Trace the foundation of the figure used to determine the levy. The gross tonnage figure (1,840) is stated as the basis for setting the levy charge, but the document does not identify, cite, or name the underlying source document from which this figure was read. 3. EVALUATE: According to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (id="L1"), in a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from. Failure to name the document deprives the charge of support. The author has set the levy from the gross tonnage figure of 1,840 without naming the document from which it was read. 4. SYNTHESIZE: The entry contains an omission of a mandatory source document reference under Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1. Because the claim stating the figure is present in the text but omits the required source document, this is an omission with evidence type STATED_CLAIM.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Omission of source document
- Förklaring
- The record sets a levy charge based on a gross tonnage figure of 1,840 but fails to name the document from which the figure was read, violating the mandatory requirement in Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
- Utelämnande
- Ja · ett påstående saknar det som krävs av det
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Körning 2
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The document is a record entitled 'Levy entry LV-440'. Under the heading 'Basis of the charge', it states: 'The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.' and 'The levy was set from that tonnage.' Under 'Levy result', it states: 'The harbour levy is recorded as payable in full.' 2. TRACE: Tracing the figure 1,840 backward in the text reveals that no source document (such as a tonnage certificate, ship register, or manifest) is identified or referenced anywhere in the record. 3. EVALUATE: According to the Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (law L1), in a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from; otherwise, the figure provides no support for the charge, and the duty rests on the author. The record sets the levy from the figure 1,840 but omits the name of the document from which that figure was read. 4. SYNTHESIZE: Formulate a single flaw object recording this omission under STATED_CLAIM, citing law L1.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Omission of source document
- Förklaring
- The levy entry establishes a charge based on a gross tonnage figure of 1,840 but fails to name the document from which the figure was read, contrary to the requirement that every levy entry setting a charge from a figure must name the source document.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
- Utelämnande
- Ja · ett påstående saknar det som krävs av det
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Körning 3
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The document is a record entitled 'Levy entry LV-440'. Under 'Ship calling', it states that 'The cargo ship Marta Holm called at the south quay.' Under 'Basis of the charge', it states that 'The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.' and 'The levy was set from that tonnage.' Under 'Levy result', it states that 'The harbour levy is recorded as payable in full.' 2. TRACE: Tracing the basis of the charge, the investigator sets the levy based on the gross tonnage figure of 1,840. Tracing the origin of this figure within the document reveals no citation, title, or reference to the document from which the figure of 1,840 was obtained or read. 3. EVALUATE: According to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (L1), in a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from, and the duty rests on the author of the record. The text records the figure and sets the charge from it without naming the source document. 4. SYNTHESIZE: The record contains a stated claim setting a charge from a figure while omitting the required document reference. This is an omission with stated claim evidence under L1.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Missing source document
- Förklaring
- The levy entry sets a charge from the figure of 1,840 gross tonnage but does not name the document from which the figure was read, failing to comply with Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
- Utelämnande
- Ja · ett påstående saknar det som krävs av det
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Körning efter en ändring i motorn,
Det här testfallet i varje körning av omgången. Testfall Körning 1 Körning 2 Körning 3 Bedömt mot version 1Endast granskarenSamma fynd i varje körning - charged-figure-without-document Brist: hittad, på rätt textställe och med rätt regel
Inga fynd utöver facit
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
- charged-figure-without-document Brist: hittad, på rätt textställe och med rätt regel
Inga fynd utöver facit
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
- charged-figure-without-document Brist: hittad, på rätt textställe och med rätt regel
Inga fynd utöver facit
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
Se motorns egna svar
Det här är motorns egna svar, på den engelska den skrev dem, visade precis som de kom tillbaka och oredigerade. Upprepningarna står sida vid sida, så att du själv kan se hur formuleringarna varierar även när det poängsatta resultatet är detsamma.
System- och användarprompterna som motorn fick publiceras inte: de hör till produkten, inte till testet. Dokumentet, reglerna och instruktionen som testet gav visas ovan.
Körning 1
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The document contains the following factual claims and administrative determinations: 'The cargo ship Marta Holm called at the south quay.', 'The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.', 'The levy was set from that tonnage.', and 'The harbour levy is recorded as payable in full.' 2. TRACE: Tracing the figure used to determine the levy ('1,840'), the text states that the gross tonnage was 1,840 and that the levy was set from that tonnage. However, there is no reference to any document, measurement certificate, or report from which this figure was read. 3. EVALUATE: According to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (id="L1"), in a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from. A figure whose document is not named gives the charge no support. The document type is a record, and the author omitted the mandatory source document for the figure of 1,840 gross tonnage. 4. SYNTHESIZE: Record a single flaw for the omission of the required source document under the heading 'Basis of the charge', citing L1.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Missing source document reference
- Förklaring
- The levy entry establishes a charge based on a figure (gross tonnage of 1,840) but omits naming the document from which the figure was read, contrary to the mandatory requirement in Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
- Utelämnande
- Ja
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Körning 2
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The document contains a levy entry (LV-440) which records that the gross tonnage of the cargo ship Marta Holm was 1,840, that the levy was set from that tonnage, and that the harbour levy is recorded as payable in full. 2. TRACE: Tracing the figure '1,840' backward in the document, there is no mention of the document or source from which this gross tonnage figure was read. 3. EVALUATE: According to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (L1), in a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from. Since the author of the record failed to name the source document for the figure 1,840, this constitutes a procedural omission under binding law L1. 4. SYNTHESIZE: Document the omission as a flaw anchored on L1.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Missing document reference
- Förklaring
- The levy entry sets a charge from the figure of 1,840 gross tonnage but omits naming the document from which the figure was read, failing the mandatory requirement that every levy entry setting a charge from a figure must name its source document.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
- Utelämnande
- Ja
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Körning 3
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The document is a record containing a levy entry (LV-440) regarding the cargo ship Marta Holm calling at the south quay. Under 'Basis of the charge', the author states: 'The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.' and 'The levy was set from that tonnage.' Under 'Levy result', the author concludes: 'The harbour levy is recorded as payable in full.' 2. TRACE: The figure of 1,840 gross tonnage is stated as the factual basis for setting the levy. Tracing this figure backwards through the record reveals no mention of the source document or record from which the figure of 1,840 was obtained or read. 3. EVALUATE: According to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (L1), in a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from. The author failed to identify or name the source document for the gross tonnage figure of 1,840. 4. SYNTHESIZE: This constitutes an omission on a stated claim where a required statutory element (naming the source document) is missing. Therefore, is_omission is set to true, quoting the claim regarding the gross tonnage figure.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Missing document reference
- Förklaring
- The levy entry sets a charge based on a figure (gross tonnage of 1,840) but omits naming the document from which the figure was read, contrary to the mandatory requirement in Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
- Utelämnande
- Ja
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Körning efter en ändring i motorn,
Det här testfallet i varje körning av omgången. Testfall Körning 1 Körning 2 Körning 3 Bedömt mot version 1Endast granskarenSamma fynd i varje körning - charged-figure-without-document Brist: hittad, på rätt textställe och med rätt regel
Inga fynd utöver facit
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
- charged-figure-without-document Brist: hittad, på rätt textställe och med rätt regel
Inga fynd utöver facit
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
- charged-figure-without-document Brist: hittad, på rätt textställe och med rätt regel
Inga fynd utöver facit
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
Se motorns egna svar
Det här är motorns egna svar, på den engelska den skrev dem, visade precis som de kom tillbaka och oredigerade. Upprepningarna står sida vid sida, så att du själv kan se hur formuleringarna varierar även när det poängsatta resultatet är detsamma.
System- och användarprompterna som motorn fick publiceras inte: de hör till produkten, inte till testet. Dokumentet, reglerna och instruktionen som testet gav visas ovan.
Körning 1
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: In the record 'Levy entry LV-440', the author states that the cargo ship Marta Holm called at the south quay, states that 'The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840', asserts that 'The levy was set from that tonnage', and concludes that 'The harbour levy is recorded as payable in full'. 2. TRACE: Tracing the origin of the gross tonnage figure (1,840) used to set the levy, the document states the numerical figure but does not state, cite, or name any underlying document from which this figure was read. 3. EVALUATE: Under Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (L1), in a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from, and a figure whose document is not named gives the charge no support. The author of the record has the duty to name the document. The author failed to name the source document for the gross tonnage figure used to set the levy. 4. SYNTHESIZE: The record contains a procedural omission under Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1, because it sets the levy based on the tonnage figure of 1,840 without naming the document from which the figure was retrieved.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Missing source document
- Förklaring
- The record sets a levy charge from the gross tonnage figure of 1,840 but fails to name the document from which the figure was read, contrary to the mandatory requirement in Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
- Utelämnande
- Ja
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Körning 2
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The document contains statements regarding a ship calling ('The cargo ship Marta Holm called at the south quay.'), the basis of the charge ('The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.' and 'The levy was set from that tonnage.'), and the levy result ('The harbour levy is recorded as payable in full.'). 2. TRACE: The figure of 1,840 gross tonnage is used directly to establish and calculate the harbour levy. However, tracing the origin of this figure within the record reveals that no source document or certificate is identified or cited. 3. EVALUATE: Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (Law L1) requires that in a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from, placing this obligation directly on the author of the record. The document completely omits the name of the document from which the figure of 1,840 was read. 4. SYNTHESIZE: The entry fails to comply with Law L1 because the charged figure lacks identification of its underlying source document. This constitutes a procedural omission tied to a specific stated claim.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Missing source document
- Förklaring
- The record sets a levy charge from a gross tonnage figure of 1,840 without naming the document from which the figure was read, contrary to the requirement that every levy entry setting a charge from a figure must name the source document.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
Sida: Page 1 - Utelämnande
- Ja
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Körning 3
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The document contains a levy entry (LV-440) regarding the cargo ship Marta Holm calling at the south quay. Under the section 'Basis of the charge', it states: 'The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.' and 'The levy was set from that tonnage.' Under 'Levy result', it states: 'The harbour levy is recorded as payable in full.' 2. TRACE: The figure used to set the levy is the gross tonnage figure of 1,840. Tracing this figure backwards through the record reveals no mention, citation, or reference identifying the document from which this figure was obtained or read. 3. EVALUATE: According to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (L1), in a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from, placing the duty on the author. A figure whose document is not named gives the charge no support. The author set the levy based on the gross tonnage figure of 1,840 without naming the underlying document. 4. SYNTHESIZE: The entry fails to comply with the mandatory requirement of L1 due to the omission of the source document reference for the charged figure. No procedural strengths or norm conflicts are present under the provided framework.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Missing document reference
- Förklaring
- The levy entry sets a charge based on a gross tonnage figure of 1,840 but fails to name the document from which the figure was read, contrary to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
Sida: Throughout - Utelämnande
- Ja
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Körning efter en ändring i motorn,
Det här testfallet i varje körning av omgången. Testfall Körning 1 Körning 2 Körning 3 Bedömt mot version 1Endast granskarenSamma fynd i varje körning - charged-figure-without-document Brist: inte hittad, men regeln nämndes i ett annat fynd
1 oväntad brist
- Hänvisade till: Regel A
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
- charged-figure-without-document Brist: inte hittad, men regeln nämndes i ett annat fynd
1 oväntad brist
- Hänvisade till: Regel A
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
- charged-figure-without-document Brist: inte hittad, men regeln nämndes i ett annat fynd
1 oväntad brist
- Hänvisade till: Regel A
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
Se motorns egna svar
Det här är motorns egna svar, på den engelska den skrev dem, visade precis som de kom tillbaka och oredigerade. Upprepningarna står sida vid sida, så att du själv kan se hur formuleringarna varierar även när det poängsatta resultatet är detsamma.
System- och användarprompterna som motorn fick publiceras inte: de hör till produkten, inte till testet. Dokumentet, reglerna och instruktionen som testet gav visas ovan.
Körning 1
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The document contains a levy record (Levy entry LV-440) for the ship Marta Holm, stating that 'The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840' and that 'The levy was set from that tonnage.' 2. TRACE: Tracing the origin of the gross tonnage figure (1,840), the text does not identify or cite any underlying certificate, register, or document from which the figure was obtained. 3. EVALUATE: According to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (L1), every levy entry in a record that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from; otherwise, the figure provides no support for the charge. The record omits this mandatory source identification. 4. SYNTHESIZE: Formulate a single flaw identifying the omission of the required source document under the heading 'Basis of the charge'.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Missing source document
- Förklaring
- The record sets a levy charge from a figure (gross tonnage of 1,840) without naming the document from which the figure was read, in deviation from the requirement in Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840. The levy was set from that tonnage.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
- Utelämnande
- Ja
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Körning 2
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The investigator records in the levy entry that the gross tonnage of the ship Marta Holm was 1,840 and that the levy was set from that tonnage ('The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840. The levy was set from that tonnage.'). 2. TRACE: Tracing the figure '1,840' in the text reveals that no underlying document or record is cited or named as the source from which the figure was read. 3. EVALUATE: According to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (L1), in a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from, and a figure whose document is not named gives the charge no support. The document fails to provide this required document name. 4. SYNTHESIZE: Record this omission as a procedural and legal flaw under L1.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Omission of source document
- Förklaring
- The levy entry sets a charge from a figure (gross tonnage of 1,840) without naming the document from which the figure was read, contrary to the mandatory requirement in Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840. The levy was set from that tonnage.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
- Utelämnande
- Ja
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Körning 3
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The record sets a levy charge based on a gross tonnage figure of 1,840 under the heading 'Basis of the charge' ('The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840. The levy was set from that tonnage.'). 2. TRACE: Tracing the figure 1,840 backward in the document reveals no mention of any source document or certificate from which this gross tonnage figure was obtained. 3. EVALUATE: Under Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (L1), every levy entry in a record that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from. Failing to name the document deprives the charge of support. The document completely omits the source document for the figure of 1,840. 4. SYNTHESIZE: Formulate a single flaw for the omission of the required source document under L1.
1 brist rapporterad
- Kategori
- Omission of source document
- Förklaring
- The record sets a levy charge based on a figure of 1,840 gross tonnage but omits naming the document from which the figure was read, contrary to Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1, which mandates that every levy entry setting a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from.
- Citat
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840. The levy was set from that tonnage.
- Var
- Under the heading Basis of the chargeCiterad rubrik:
Basis of the charge
- Utelämnande
- Ja
- Åberopad regel
- L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1 (STATUTE)
0 styrkor rapporterade
Kontroll: motorn körd med fel regler
Visas skild från resultaten. Motorn fick ett annat falls regler, så varje fynd nedan är ett fynd mot regler som inte gäller det här dokumentet.
Det här testfallet i varje körning av omgången. Testfall Körning 1 Bedömt mot version 2Endast granskaren - charged-figure-without-document Brist: missad
Inga fynd utöver facit
Inget förbjudet fynd
Citat: 0 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart
Se motorns egna svar
Det här är motorns egna svar, på den engelska den skrev dem, visade precis som de kom tillbaka och oredigerade. Upprepningarna står sida vid sida, så att du själv kan se hur formuleringarna varierar även när det poängsatta resultatet är detsamma.
System- och användarprompterna som motorn fick publiceras inte: de hör till produkten, inte till testet. Dokumentet, reglerna och instruktionen som testet gav visas ovan.
Körning 1
Språk som motorn angav: English
Motorns resonemang
1. SCAN: The document contains a record of a levy entry (LV-440) for the cargo ship Marta Holm calling at the south quay, stating the tonnage basis (1,840 gross tonnage) and that the harbour levy is payable in full. 2. TRACE: The statements detail the calling of the vessel and the levy calculation. 3. EVALUATE: The sole binding provision in the legal framework is L1 (Entry Practice Schedule, part R, issue 1), which stipulates that every berthing entry in a record that states a vessel was moved must name the person who ordered the move. The document contains no statement or entry indicating that a vessel was moved. 4. SYNTHESIZE: As the condition of a vessel being moved is not present in the document, no procedural or legal requirement under L1 is violated, nor is there a direct positive statutory compliance to report as a strength under L1.
0 brister rapporterade
0 styrkor rapporterade
Tidigare versioner av det här testfallet
En rättad grupp publiceras bredvid den version som tidigare resultat bedömdes mot.
Gruppversion 1
Vad det här testfallet ändrar
- Faktor
- the passage the rule would be applied to
- Nivå
- present and unsourced
- Jämförs med
- basis-withheldÄndringen ska ändra svaret. Ett textställe i dokumentet skiljer sig mellan de två.
The levy is set from a tonnage the entry does not source.
Dokumentet motorn fick
Exakt den text motorn fick, rad för rad.
- Levy entry LV-440
- Ship calling
- The cargo ship Marta Holm called at the south quay.
- Basis of the charge
- The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- The levy was set from that tonnage.
- Levy result
- The harbour levy is recorded as payable in full.
Reglerna motorn fick
Varje regel visas under en neutral beteckning i stället för sitt interna namn.
Regel A
The document a charged figure was read from
Källa: Entry Practice Schedule, part P, issue 1
In a record, every levy entry that sets a charge from a figure must name the document the figure was read from. A figure whose document is not named gives the charge no support. The duty rests on the author of the record.
Facit
Skrevs ner innan motorn kördes. unsourced-figure-truth
The charge is set from a stated figure and the entry names no document for it.
Facit är uttömmande: varje fynd som inte står som förväntat räknas som fel.
Förväntade fynd
- BristUtelämnandeFynd charged-figure-without-document
The entry sets the levy from a figure and names no document it was read from.
- Ska förankras i
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Ska hänvisa till
- Regel A
- Kontrolleras i
- granskarens eget utfall, den levererade rapporten
Förbjudna fynd
Fel svar, nedskrivna i förväg.
- StyrkaFynd unsourced-figure-praised
Crediting the figure for naming its document when it names none.
- Ska förankras i
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Ska hänvisa till
- Regel A
- Kontrolleras i
- granskarens eget utfall, den levererade rapporten
Vad den blinda läsaren svarade
En AI-läsare fick det här dokumentet och dess regler, men inte facit, och svarade på egen hand. Jämför svaret med facit ovan.
- Överens med facitClaude, 23 september 2026Punkt i läsarens underlag item-02
- BristUtelämnandeRegel A
Ska förankras i
The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840.
- Inte överens med facitGemini, 4 oktober 2026Punkt i läsarens underlag item-17
- BristUtelämnandeRegel A
Ska förankras i
The levy was set from that tonnage.
Kritisk granskning av facit
En AI-modellsession försökte hitta fel i det här facit enligt ett publicerat protokoll: är varje väntat fynd verkligen ett brott mot regeln, är varje felfritt fall verkligen felfritt, prövar fallet det det säger sig pröva, och skulle ett lika riktigt svar som pekar på ett annat ställe räknas som fel. Den tittade inte på motorns resultat först. Varje invändning visas med hur den avgjordes. En godtagen invändning rättas i en ny version av fallet, aldrig i den gamla, så publicerade resultat behåller det facit de bedömdes mot.
Granskning av Claude, 4 oktober 2026
- Facit svagtFörankringRegel Ap1 · charged-figure-without-document
Rule A's duty attaches to an entry that "sets a charge from a figure". That act is its own line, "The levy was set from that tonnage.", while the key anchors the omission on the line above, "The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840." An omission anchored on the setting of the charge is as correct as the key's, but the scorer accepts a wider quote only on the anchor's own line, so it is scored as a miss and an unexpected flaw.
Godtagen, rättelse väntar · rättelsen följs upp i #3075
A correct answer must not be scored as two errors. The family is corrected under a new version in which the figure and the charge set from it are one sentence.
- Invändning besvaradGiltighetRegel Ap4
Gäller hela gruppen av fall
The family carries the outcome unsupported-factual-claim, but structurally it is a claim-anchored omission under a rule that says what support is required, the same shape as the cure and refusal families. It does not test spotting an unsupported claim no rule describes.
Facit står kvar
The engine audits a document against supplied rules, so a claim is unsupported in the sense a supplied rule defines. The family's rule is what makes the figure unsupported; that is what the outcome names.
Testets instruktion till granskaren
Testkonfigurationen gav AI-granskaren den här instruktionen vid sidan av reglerna. Det är testets egen instruktion. Produktionens systemprompt visas inte.
You read one document and apply only the rules supplied to you in the legal framework, exactly as each rule is written. Report every place where the document does not meet a supplied rule, and apply what a supplied rule says about how a record that meets it is to be recorded. Quote each passage exactly as it appears. Do not apply a rule that was not supplied, and do not rely on any knowledge of a legal system.Vem som skrev och läste det här testfallet
En AI-modellsession skrev de här testfallen, och en annan AI-modellsession läste dem blint utan att se facit. Ingen människa har granskat dem.
- Skrevs
- , registrerat som Verkstaden implementer (Claude Local), #2323
- Modellfamilj som skrev det
- Claude
- Varför det skrevs
- Authored for #2323 as new REGRESSION material in the outcome shapes of the controlled-pilot suite, sharing none of its text. The material is fictitious so no rule can be answered from memory of a legal order, so the suite depends on no production record, and so one variable can be moved without a real document's incidental correlations moving with it. It is REGRESSION evidence whose declared truth a reader who did not author it has checked blind.
Granskning
Skrivna av en AI-modellsession: Claude.
Blind läsning, Claude, 23 september 2026: 22 av 22 överens
registrerat som Verkstaden orchestrator session (Claude Opus 5.5), blind read
Ingen oenighet med facit.
Se vad den blinda läsaren svarade i varje testfallBlind läsning, Gemini, 4 oktober 2026: 19 av 22 överens
registrerat som gemini-2.5-pro (Vertex europe-west1), blind read
Se vad den blinda läsaren svarade i varje testfall3 oenigheter med facit
Punkt item-06
The reader found the closure entry's missing statement of where its papers are stored, as declared, but placed it under the "Closing note" heading; the key places it under no section.
Hur den avgjordes
Genuinely ambiguous: the rule attaches the duty to the whole entry, but a closing note is a natural home for it, and the packet does not say which. Kept as declared; #3082 sharpens the case.
Punkt item-07
The reader agreed nothing is due for the sample run from a tap, but gave the reason as a condition not triggered; the key declares the sample out of the rule's scope.
Hur den avgjordes
Genuinely ambiguous: the packet names the four reasons without defining them, and the rule's wording reads both as a scope limit and as an unmet condition. Kept as declared; #3083 sharpens the reasons.
Punkt item-17
The reader found the levy charged from a figure with no named document, as declared, but quoted the sentence that sets the levy; the key anchors the flaw on the sentence that states the figure.
Hur den avgjordes
Reader wrong: the rule's duty attaches to the figure ("a figure whose document is not named"), and the packet anchors an unsupported claim on the claim itself, which here is the figure, not the charge set from it.
Kritisk granskning, Claude, 4 oktober 2026: 1 invändning
registrerat som Claude Project thread session for #3049, adversarial critique
1 oenighet med facit
Punkt p1 (figure-without-document, charged-figure-without-document)
KEY_WEAK, ANCHORING: Rule A's duty attaches to an entry that "sets a charge from a figure". That act is its own line, "The levy was set from that tonnage.", while the key anchors the omission on the line above, "The gross tonnage of the ship was 1,840." An omission anchored on the setting of the charge is as correct as the key's, but the scorer accepts a wider quote only on the anchor's own line, so it is scored as a miss and an unexpected flaw.
Hur den avgjordes
ACCEPTED: A correct answer must not be scored as two errors. The family is corrected under a new version in which the figure and the charge set from it are one sentence. Follow-up #3075.
AI-modeller skrev och granskade de här testfallen, som anges ovan. Ingen människa har granskat dem. Varje oenighet mellan en AI-granskare och facit publiceras här.
Fingeravtryck
SHA-256-hashvärden som en läsare kan jämföra med en publicerad körnings rapport.
- Dokument
- 98180581ad9bfe09a7cc9923acff073b7a099337f002b09c98ceb3b4b76ea369
- Dokumentmall
- 1e2f522c3a8a20b3c8c8b90f93181b5e09a2fc9c59e8813d37cb50f566d3dd3f
- Regel A
- fa3928d90b453dd2d705189e5d07ab64c11337803e039b0f60e0ab3268b5a7d6