GRANSKA
Logga inSkapa konto
Alla testfall

Testfall · A duty owed by every entry of its kind, with and without the sentence that meets it

papers-location-stated

Grupp
regression-unconditional-duty · Gruppversion 2
Testsvit
Testsvit controlled-regression, version 1
Evidensklass
REGRESSION

The engine reports a closure entry that says nothing about where its papers are stored as an omission with no passage to quote, and reports nothing when the same entry says where.

Testdokumenten, reglerna och facit visas på engelska, det språk de skrevs på.

Vad det här testfallet ändrar

Faktor
stated place where the original papers are stored
Nivå
present
Jämförs med
papers-location-unstatedÄndringen ska ändra svaret. Ett textställe i dokumentet skiljer sig mellan de två.

The same entry, saying where the original papers are stored.

Dokumentet motorn fick

Exakt den text motorn fick, rad för rad.

  1. Closure entry CL-507
  2. Matter closed
  3. The complaint about night noise at the ferry ramp was closed.
  4. Complainant informed
  5. The complainant was told of the closure by telephone on 3 June 2032.
  6. Original papers
  7. The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.

Reglerna motorn fick

Varje regel visas under en neutral beteckning i stället för sitt interna namn.

  • Regel A

    Where the original papers are stored

    Källa: Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1

    In a record, every closure entry must say where the original papers behind it are stored. Each closure entry owes this whatever its matter, without first mentioning papers at all. The duty rests on the author of the record.

Regler dokumentet redan uppfyller

  • Regel A

    Uppfylls av det här textstället

    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.

Facit

Skrevs ner innan motorn kördes. papers-location-stated-truth

The same entry, saying where the papers are stored. The rule carries no crediting clause, so nothing is due either way.

Facit är uttömmande: varje fynd som inte står som förväntat räknas som fel.

Förväntade fynd

Inget fynd förväntas.

Varför inget ska rapporteras
Dokumentet uppfyller varje regel det fick. COMPLIANT

Förbjudna fynd

Fel svar, nedskrivna i förväg.

  • BristUtelämnandeFynd false-unstated-papers-location

    Reporting the papers' location as missing when the entry states it is a false positive, and an unlocated one is how this family's true target looks.

    Ska förankras i
    Förankras inte i något textställe, eftersom dokumentet aldrig nämner steget
    Ska hänvisa till
    Regel A
    Kontrolleras i
    granskarens eget utfall, den levererade rapporten

Vad den blinda läsaren svarade

En AI-läsare fick det här dokumentet och dess regler, men inte facit, och svarade på egen hand. Jämför svaret med facit ovan.

  • Inte överens med facitGemini, 5 oktober 2026Punkt i läsarens underlag item-02
    • StyrkaRegel A

      Ska förankras i The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.

Kritisk granskning av facit

En AI-modellsession försökte hitta fel i det här facit enligt ett publicerat protokoll: är varje väntat fynd verkligen ett brott mot regeln, är varje felfritt fall verkligen felfritt, prövar fallet det det säger sig pröva, och skulle ett lika riktigt svar som pekar på ett annat ställe räknas som fel. Den tittade inte på motorns resultat först. Varje invändning visas med hur den avgjordes. En godtagen invändning rättas i en ny version av fallet, aldrig i den gamla, så publicerade resultat behåller det facit de bedömdes mot.

Ingen kritisk granskning av det här facit finns registrerad.

Testets instruktion till granskaren

Testkonfigurationen gav AI-granskaren den här instruktionen vid sidan av reglerna. Det är testets egen instruktion. Produktionens systemprompt visas inte.

You read one document and apply only the rules supplied to you in the legal framework, exactly as each rule is written. Report every place where the document does not meet a supplied rule, and apply what a supplied rule says about how a record that meets it is to be recorded. Quote each passage exactly as it appears. Do not apply a rule that was not supplied, and do not rely on any knowledge of a legal system.

Vem som skrev och läste det här testfallet

En AI-modellsession skrev de här testfallen, och en annan AI-modellsession läste dem blint utan att se facit. Ingen människa har granskat dem.

Skrevs
, registrerat som Claude Project thread session for #3082
Modellfamilj som skrev det
Claude
Varför det skrevs
Authored for #2323 as new REGRESSION material in the outcome shapes of the controlled-pilot suite, sharing none of its text. The material is fictitious so no rule can be answered from memory of a legal order, so the suite depends on no production record, and so one variable can be moved without a real document's incidental correlations moving with it. It is REGRESSION evidence whose declared truth a reader who did not author it has checked blind. Version 2 corrects version 1 for #3082: a blind reader placed the missing statement of where the papers are stored under the entry's closing note, a defensible home the key did not allow. Version 2 drops that section and gives the stated side's sentence a heading of its own.

Granskning

Skrivna av en AI-modellsession: Claude.

  • Blind läsning, Gemini, 5 oktober 2026: 1 av 2 överens

    registrerat som gemini-2.5-pro (Vertex europe-west1), blind read

    1 oenighet med facit

    • Punkt item-02

      The reader found the duty met by the sentence that says where the papers are stored, as declared, but credited that sentence as a strength; the key declares the entry compliant and credits nothing.

      Hur den avgjordes

      Reader over-credits: doing what the rule requires, and no more, is compliance, not a strength. Kept as declared.

    Se vad den blinda läsaren svarade i varje testfall

AI-modeller skrev och granskade de här testfallen, som anges ovan. Ingen människa har granskat dem. Varje oenighet mellan en AI-granskare och facit publiceras här.

Fingeravtryck

SHA-256-hashvärden som en läsare kan jämföra med en publicerad körnings rapport.

Dokument
10959a33b3c8f0e43a1467090d89842940fd1cef080cae42008a8ce0c72d2aa0
Dokumentmall
aa450261fa4e8225c1db9e713ace8affc46b4c8bf412c4abd533b31e8276db0e
Regel A
9179015ff26a2a0761ed1900dcb9a8b4361adb49cc61403b42fc4ab93235e471

Resultat i publicerade körningar

Senaste först. Varje kolumn är en körning av det här testfallet.

  1. Mätkörning med releasedesignen, ingen release,

    Det här testfallet i varje körning av omgången.
    TestfallKörning 1Körning 2Körning 3Körning 4Körning 5
    Bedömt mot version 1Endast granskarenSamma fynd i varje körning

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Se motorns egna svar

    Det här är motorns egna svar, på den engelska den skrev dem, visade precis som de kom tillbaka och oredigerade. Upprepningarna står sida vid sida, så att du själv kan se hur formuleringarna varierar även när det poängsatta resultatet är detsamma.

    System- och användarprompterna som motorn fick publiceras inte: de hör till produkten, inte till testet. Dokumentet, reglerna och instruktionen som testet gav visas ovan.

    Körning 1

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: The document is a closure entry (CL-507) documenting the closure of a complaint regarding night noise at the ferry ramp. It states that the complainant was informed on 3 June 2032, notes that no further work is required, and specifies that 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' 2. TRACE: The statement regarding the storage location of the original papers directly addresses the record-keeping location for the matter. 3. EVALUATE: The single applicable binding rule is Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (id: L1), which mandates that in a record, every closure entry must state where the original papers behind it are stored. The document explicitly includes the sentence: 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' Therefore, the document fully complies with L1, and there are no legal or procedural deviations. 4. SYNTHESIZE: Formulate a procedural strength regarding compliance with L1 and return an empty array for identified flaws and norm conflicts.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry explicitly states the storage location of the original records behind the closed matter, complying with the statutory requirement for closure entries.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Sida:
    Page 1
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

    Körning 2

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: The document is a record containing 'Closure entry CL-507'. It states the matter is closed ('The complaint about night noise at the ferry ramp was closed'), the closing steps taken ('The complainant was told of the closure by telephone on 3 June 2032'), and a closing note ('The matter needs no further work. The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.'). 2. TRACE: The legal framework contains a single binding requirement under law id L1 (Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1), mandating that in a record, every closure entry must say where the original papers behind it are stored. 3. EVALUATE: Checking the text against L1, the closure entry explicitly specifies: 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' Thus, the document fully satisfies the statutory requirement. 4. SYNTHESIZE: There are no legal or procedural flaws under the provided framework. A strength is recorded for compliance with L1.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry explicitly documents the storage location of the original papers behind the closure, in full compliance with the statutory duty.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Sida:
    Page 1
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

    Körning 3

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: Identified the elements of the record: closure of complaint CL-507 regarding night noise at the ferry ramp, notification of complainant on 3 June 2032, closing note that the matter requires no further work, and the statement that original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office. 2. TRACE: Traced the closure statement regarding the storage location of the original documents. 3. EVALUATE: Evaluated the text against the sole provided binding legal provision, Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (L1), which requires that every closure entry in a record state where the original papers behind it are stored. The document explicitly includes this information ('The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.'). No violations of the provided legal framework exist. 4. SYNTHESIZE: Document conforms to L1; no flaws found. Recorded one procedural strength regarding compliance with the storage location recording duty.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry explicitly records the physical storage location of the original papers behind the closure, in full compliance with the mandatory requirement.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Sida:
    Throughout
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

    Körning 4

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: The document is a closure entry (CL-507) for a complaint regarding night noise at a ferry ramp. It states that the complaint was closed, the complainant was informed by telephone on 3 June 2032, the matter requires no further work, and 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' 2. TRACE: The statement concerning document retention specifies the precise physical location where the underlying original records are kept ('cabinet 12 of the east office'). 3. EVALUATE: Under Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (L1), every closure entry in a record must state where the original papers behind it are stored, irrespective of the subject matter. The text explicitly provides this information. 4. SYNTHESIZE: The closure entry is fully compliant with the sole provided binding legal requirement. No flaws or norm conflicts are present. One procedural strength is noted for compliance with L1.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry explicitly documents the storage location of the original papers, satisfying the mandatory requirement for closure entries in records.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

    Körning 5

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: Identified all procedural elements and statements in the document: closure of the complaint regarding night noise at the ferry ramp, notification to the complainant on 3 June 2032 by telephone, a note that the matter requires no further work, and a specific statement that the original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office. 2. TRACE: Traced the paper storage statement directly to the legal requirement under Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (L1), which obligates the author of a record closure entry to state where the original papers behind it are stored. 3. EVALUATE: Assessed the closure entry against L1. The document explicitly includes the required statement: "The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office." No deviations or omissions were found under the supplied legal framework. 4. SYNTHESIZE: Recorded zero identified flaws, no norm conflicts, and documented the procedural compliance as a strength grounded in L1.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry explicitly records where the original papers behind the record are stored, fully satisfying the statutory requirement.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

  2. Schemalagd nattkörning,

    Det här testfallet i varje körning av omgången.
    TestfallKörning 1
    Bedömt mot version 1Endast granskaren

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Se motorns egna svar

    Det här är motorns egna svar, på den engelska den skrev dem, visade precis som de kom tillbaka och oredigerade. Upprepningarna står sida vid sida, så att du själv kan se hur formuleringarna varierar även när det poängsatta resultatet är detsamma.

    System- och användarprompterna som motorn fick publiceras inte: de hör till produkten, inte till testet. Dokumentet, reglerna och instruktionen som testet gav visas ovan.

    Körning 1

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: The document is a record containing closure entry CL-507 regarding a closed complaint about night noise at a ferry ramp. It documents the closure, notification to the complainant, closing note, and specifies: 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' 2. TRACE: The statement regarding the storage location of the original papers directly addresses the storage of the records underlying the closure entry. 3. EVALUATE: According to the binding law (Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1), every closure entry in a record must state where the original papers behind it are stored. The document explicitly includes this information ('The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.'). No legal or procedural violations are observed. 4. SYNTHESIZE: There are no legal flaws. The inclusion of the exact storage location of the original papers constitutes a procedural strength under the provided framework.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry explicitly records where the original papers behind the closure are stored, fully complying with the requirement that every closure entry in a record must indicate the storage location of the underlying original papers.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Sida:
    Throughout
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

  3. Schemalagd nattkörning,

    Det här testfallet i varje körning av omgången.
    TestfallKörning 1
    Bedömt mot version 1Endast granskaren

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Se motorns egna svar

    Det här är motorns egna svar, på den engelska den skrev dem, visade precis som de kom tillbaka och oredigerade. Upprepningarna står sida vid sida, så att du själv kan se hur formuleringarna varierar även när det poängsatta resultatet är detsamma.

    System- och användarprompterna som motorn fick publiceras inte: de hör till produkten, inte till testet. Dokumentet, reglerna och instruktionen som testet gav visas ovan.

    Körning 1

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: The document is a record consisting of closure entry CL-507, noting that a complaint regarding night noise at the ferry ramp was closed, communication steps taken with the complainant, and a closing note stating that the matter needs no further work and that 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' 2. TRACE: The statement regarding the storage location of the original papers is made directly in the closing note of the record. 3. EVALUATE: Under L1 (Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1), every closure entry in a record must state where the original papers behind it are stored. The document explicitly includes this information ('The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.'). There are no omissions, procedural deviations, or conflicting provisions in the provided legal framework. 4. SYNTHESIZE: The document fully satisfies the requirements of L1. No legal or procedural flaws are identified. One procedural strength is noted for compliance with L1.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry explicitly specifies the physical storage location of the original papers behind it, fulfilling the mandatory requirement for closure entries in records.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

  4. Körning efter en ändring i motorn,

    Det här testfallet i varje körning av omgången.
    TestfallKörning 1Körning 2Körning 3
    Bedömt mot version 1Endast granskarenSamma fynd i varje körning

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Se motorns egna svar

    Det här är motorns egna svar, på den engelska den skrev dem, visade precis som de kom tillbaka och oredigerade. Upprepningarna står sida vid sida, så att du själv kan se hur formuleringarna varierar även när det poängsatta resultatet är detsamma.

    System- och användarprompterna som motorn fick publiceras inte: de hör till produkten, inte till testet. Dokumentet, reglerna och instruktionen som testet gav visas ovan.

    Körning 1

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: The document is a closure entry record (CL-507) regarding a closed complaint about ferry ramp night noise, documenting closing steps, telephone contact on 3 June 2032, and note stating 'The matter needs no further work. The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' 2. TRACE: Tracing against the legal framework, Law L1 (Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1) imposes a mandatory duty on the author of a record that every closure entry must state where the original papers behind it are stored. 3. EVALUATE: The closure entry explicitly includes the statement: 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' This fulfills the statutory requirement set out in L1. No conflicting or additional rules are provided. 4. SYNTHESIZE: There are no legal flaws or omissions in the record. The document demonstrates full compliance with Law L1, which is noted as a procedural strength.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry explicitly specifies the exact storage location of the original papers behind the closed matter, fulfilling the procedural duty placed on the author of the record.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

    Körning 2

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: Scanned the document 'Closure entry CL-507'. The document records the closure of a complaint regarding night noise at the ferry ramp, notes closing steps taken, states that the matter needs no further work, and specifies: 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' 2. TRACE: Traced the requirement under the legal framework. The relevant legal snippet is L1 ('Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1'), which obligates the author of a record to state in every closure entry where the original papers behind it are stored. 3. EVALUATE: Evaluated the text against L1. The document explicitly includes the required statement: 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' Therefore, the closure entry satisfies all requirements of L1. 4. SYNTHESIZE: No legal flaws or omissions are present. The explicit documentation of paper storage location constitutes a procedural strength under L1.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry explicitly documents the location where the underlying original papers are stored, fulfilling the statutory requirement for closure records.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

    Körning 3

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: The document is a closure entry (CL-507) concerning a complaint about night noise at a ferry ramp. It states that the complaint was closed, the complainant was informed by telephone on 3 June 2032, no further work is needed, and 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' 2. TRACE: The statement regarding the storage location of original documents ('The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.') directly addresses the storage of the records behind closure entry CL-507. 3. EVALUATE: Under Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (L1), every closure entry in a record must state where the original papers behind it are stored. The document directly includes this required detail. 4. SYNTHESIZE: The document satisfies all requirements set forth in the provided legal framework. There are no procedural deviations or missing required steps under the supplied rules. Therefore, no flaws or norm conflicts exist, and the explicit inclusion of the storage location constitutes a procedural strength under L1.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry explicitly documents the location where the original papers behind the closure are stored, satisfying the mandatory recording obligation.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Sida:
    Page 1
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

  5. Körning efter en ändring i motorn,

    Det här testfallet i varje körning av omgången.
    TestfallKörning 1Körning 2Körning 3
    Bedömt mot version 1Endast granskarenSamma fynd i varje körning

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Se motorns egna svar

    Det här är motorns egna svar, på den engelska den skrev dem, visade precis som de kom tillbaka och oredigerade. Upprepningarna står sida vid sida, så att du själv kan se hur formuleringarna varierar även när det poängsatta resultatet är detsamma.

    System- och användarprompterna som motorn fick publiceras inte: de hör till produkten, inte till testet. Dokumentet, reglerna och instruktionen som testet gav visas ovan.

    Körning 1

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: The document is a closure entry (CL-507) for a complaint regarding night noise at a ferry ramp. It states that the matter was closed, the complainant was informed via telephone on 3 June 2032, no further work is required, and notes that 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' 2. TRACE: The applicable legal rule is L1 (Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1), which stipulates that in a record, every closure entry must state where the original papers behind it are stored. 3. EVALUATE: Comparing the document to L1, the author has explicitly specified where the original papers are kept ('The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.'). Thus, there are no statutory deviations or omissions. 4. SYNTHESIZE: The document is fully compliant with the only applicable rule in the legal framework. A procedural strength is recorded for complying with L1.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry explicitly indicates the storage location of the original records behind the closure.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Sida:
    Page 1
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

    Körning 2

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: The document is a closure entry (CL-507) for a complaint concerning night noise at the ferry ramp. It notes closure communication with the complainant on 3 June 2032, concludes that no further work is required, and states that original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office. 2. TRACE: The document's author directly records the storage location under the closing note: 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' 3. EVALUATE: According to the binding law (Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 [L1]), every closure entry in a record must state where the original papers behind it are stored. The document fulfills this specific mandatory requirement. 4. SYNTHESIZE: No legal flaws or omissions are present. The document complies fully with the provided legal framework, constituting a procedural strength.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry explicitly indicates where the underlying original papers are stored, fulfilling the mandatory documentation requirement.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Sida:
    Page 1
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

    Körning 3

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: The closure entry CL-507 documents the closure of a complaint regarding night noise at the ferry ramp, notes that the complainant was notified by telephone on 3 June 2032, provides a closing note, and includes the statement: 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' 2. TRACE: Under the provided legal framework, Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (L1) mandates that every closure entry in a record must state where the original papers behind it are stored. 3. EVALUATE: Evaluating the closure entry against L1 reveals that the author has explicitly specified the physical storage location of the original documents ('cabinet 12 of the east office'). The entry meets all mandatory elements prescribed in L1. 4. SYNTHESIZE: There are no deviations or omissions under the provided legal framework. Therefore, identified_flaws is empty and a procedural strength is recorded for compliance with L1.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry specifies the exact storage location of the original underlying papers, complying with the requirement for closure entries in records.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Sida:
    Page 1
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

  6. Körning efter en ändring i motorn,

    Det här testfallet i varje körning av omgången.
    TestfallKörning 1Körning 2Körning 3
    Bedömt mot version 1Endast granskarenSamma fynd i varje körning

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Se motorns egna svar

    Det här är motorns egna svar, på den engelska den skrev dem, visade precis som de kom tillbaka och oredigerade. Upprepningarna står sida vid sida, så att du själv kan se hur formuleringarna varierar även när det poängsatta resultatet är detsamma.

    System- och användarprompterna som motorn fick publiceras inte: de hör till produkten, inte till testet. Dokumentet, reglerna och instruktionen som testet gav visas ovan.

    Körning 1

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: The document is a closure entry (CL-507) documenting the closure of a complaint regarding night noise at the ferry ramp. It records closing steps (telephonic notification to complainant on 3 June 2032), a closing note, and a statement regarding physical storage: 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' 2. TRACE: The applicable legal framework consists of L1 (Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1), which requires that every closure entry in a record must state where the original papers behind it are stored, placing this duty on the record's author. 3. EVALUATE: Evaluating the text against L1, the closure entry explicitly states: 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' Thus, the document satisfies the statutory requirement of L1. No procedural or substantive legal deviations are identified. 4. SYNTHESIZE: As the document fully complies with the supplied binding rule, identified_flaws is empty and the adherence to L1 is documented as a legal strength.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry specifies the exact storage location of the underlying original papers, in direct compliance with the requirement that every closure entry must indicate where the original papers are stored.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

    Körning 2

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: Scanned the closure record 'Closure entry CL-507'. The document records the closure of a noise complaint, documents that the complainant was notified by telephone on 3 June 2032, notes that no further work is needed, and states that 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' 2. TRACE: The statement regarding the physical location of the case papers originates directly from the closing note in the closure record. 3. EVALUATE: The sole binding legal requirement in the provided framework is L1 (Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1), which stipulates that every closure entry in a record must state where the original papers behind it are stored. The document directly includes this exact information. 4. SYNTHESIZE: There are no legal flaws or omissions in the record under the provided legal framework. The presence of the storage location constitutes a procedural strength complying directly with L1.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry explicitly records where the original papers behind the entry are stored, in full compliance with the statutory record-keeping requirement.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Sida:
    Page 1
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

    Körning 3

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: The document constitutes a record containing a closure entry designated 'Closure entry CL-507'. It records the closure of a complaint regarding night noise at the ferry ramp, closing steps taken on 3 June 2032, and a closing note stating 'The matter needs no further work. The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' 2. TRACE: The statement concerning document storage appears directly within the closing note of closure entry CL-507. 3. EVALUATE: The applicable legal framework consists of binding law L1 ('Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1', Reference: 'Where the original papers are stored'), which mandates that in a record, every closure entry must state where the original papers behind it are stored. The closure entry CL-507 contains the explicit statement: 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' Thus, the document fully complies with the statutory requirement. 4. SYNTHESIZE: There are no legal or procedural deviations or omissions under the provided legal framework. Therefore, 'identified_flaws' is empty, and a procedural strength is recorded corresponding to compliance with L1.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry explicitly records the physical storage location of the original papers behind the closure, in full compliance with the requirement that every closure entry in a record must state where its original papers are stored.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Sida:
    Page 1
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

  7. Körning efter en ändring i motorn,

    Det här testfallet i varje körning av omgången.
    TestfallKörning 1Körning 2Körning 3
    Bedömt mot version 1Endast granskarenSamma fynd i varje körning

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Inget fynd förväntas

    1 styrka för uppfyllt krav
    • Hänvisade till: Regel A

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 1 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Se motorns egna svar

    Det här är motorns egna svar, på den engelska den skrev dem, visade precis som de kom tillbaka och oredigerade. Upprepningarna står sida vid sida, så att du själv kan se hur formuleringarna varierar även när det poängsatta resultatet är detsamma.

    System- och användarprompterna som motorn fick publiceras inte: de hör till produkten, inte till testet. Dokumentet, reglerna och instruktionen som testet gav visas ovan.

    Körning 1

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: Scanned the document 'Closure entry CL-507' for statements regarding closure, closing steps, and storage of original papers. The document contains: 'The complaint about night noise at the ferry ramp was closed.', 'The complainant was told of the closure by telephone on 3 June 2032.', 'The matter needs no further work.', and 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' 2. TRACE: Traced the mandatory requirement from the legal framework under L1 (Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1), which stipulates that every closure entry in a record must state where the original papers behind it are stored. 3. EVALUATE: Assessed the document against L1. The closure entry explicitly records the physical location where original papers are kept ('The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.'). No violations or omissions of L1 are identified. 4. SYNTHESIZE: There are no flaws. A strength is recorded for compliance with the statutory requirement under L1 regarding documentation of the storage location of original papers.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry explicitly states the storage location of the underlying original papers, in full compliance with the requirement.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Sida:
    Page 1
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

    Körning 2

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: The document is a record closure entry ('Closure entry CL-507') containing details regarding the closure of a complaint about night noise, the closing steps taken, and a closing note stating 'The matter needs no further work. The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' 2. TRACE: Tracing the requirement under the legal framework, Law L1 (Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1) requires that in a record, every closure entry must state where the original papers behind it are stored. 3. EVALUATE: Comparing the text against L1, the document explicitly states the storage location of the original papers: 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' Therefore, the document strictly complies with the rule. 4. SYNTHESIZE: There are no legal flaws or deviations under the provided framework. A strength is recorded for complying with the mandatory storage location statement required by L1.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry explicitly states the storage location of the original papers behind it, fulfilling the mandatory requirement for closure entries in records.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Sida:
    Page 1
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

    Körning 3

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: The document is a closure entry titled 'Closure entry CL-507' regarding a matter closed concerning night noise at a ferry ramp. It contains closing steps ('The complainant was told of the closure by telephone on 3 June 2032.') and a closing note stating 'The matter needs no further work.' and 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' 2. TRACE: The applicable legal framework is L1 (Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1), which requires that in a record, every closure entry must state where the original papers behind it are stored, placing this duty on the author. 3. EVALUATE: The document explicitly includes the statement 'The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.' This directly meets the mandatory requirement set forth in L1. 4. SYNTHESIZE: There are no legal flaws or omissions in the document. A procedural strength is identified for complying with L1.

    0 brister rapporterade

    1 styrka rapporterad

    Förklaring
    The closure entry specifies the exact storage location of the underlying original papers, in full compliance with the statutory record-keeping requirement.
    Citat
    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.
    Sida:
    Page 1
    Åberopad regel
    L1 · Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1 (STATUTE)

Kontroll: motorn körd med fel regler

Visas skild från resultaten. Motorn fick ett annat falls regler, så varje fynd nedan är ett fynd mot regler som inte gäller det här dokumentet.

  1. Det här testfallet i varje körning av omgången.
    TestfallKörning 1
    Bedömt mot version 2Endast granskaren

    Inget fynd förväntas

    Inga fynd utöver facit

    Inget förbjudet fynd

    Citat: 0 ordagrant, 0 påhittat, 0 obestämbart

    Rent testfall: godkänt, ingen brist rapporterades

    Se motorns egna svar

    Det här är motorns egna svar, på den engelska den skrev dem, visade precis som de kom tillbaka och oredigerade. Upprepningarna står sida vid sida, så att du själv kan se hur formuleringarna varierar även när det poängsatta resultatet är detsamma.

    System- och användarprompterna som motorn fick publiceras inte: de hör till produkten, inte till testet. Dokumentet, reglerna och instruktionen som testet gav visas ovan.

    Körning 1

    Språk som motorn angav: English

    Motorns resonemang

    1. SCAN: The document is a closure entry (CL-507) documenting the closure of a complaint regarding night noise at a ferry ramp, communication of the closure to the complainant, and physical archiving location of original papers. 2. TRACE: The legal framework contains a single binding law, Law L1 (Entry Practice Schedule, part K, issue 1), which mandates that every repair entry describing a fault as cured must name the person who checked the cure on site. 3. EVALUATE: The document does not constitute a repair entry and does not describe a fault as cured. Therefore, the requirement under Law L1 is not applicable to the text. 4. SYNTHESIZE: There are no deviations from the provided legal framework, nor are there specific actions directly mapping to the criteria of Law L1 to constitute a positive procedural strength. Hence, no flaws, norm conflicts, or strengths are identified.

    0 brister rapporterade

    0 styrkor rapporterade

Tidigare versioner av det här testfallet

En rättad grupp publiceras bredvid den version som tidigare resultat bedömdes mot.

Gruppversion 1

Vad det här testfallet ändrar

Faktor
stated place where the original papers are stored
Nivå
present
Jämförs med
papers-location-unstatedÄndringen ska ändra svaret. Ett textställe i dokumentet skiljer sig mellan de två.

The same entry, saying where the original papers are stored.

Dokumentet motorn fick

Exakt den text motorn fick, rad för rad.

  1. Closure entry CL-507
  2. Matter closed
  3. The complaint about night noise at the ferry ramp was closed.
  4. Closing steps
  5. The complainant was told of the closure by telephone on 3 June 2032.
  6. Closing note
  7. The matter needs no further work.
  8. The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.

Reglerna motorn fick

Varje regel visas under en neutral beteckning i stället för sitt interna namn.

  • Regel A

    Where the original papers are stored

    Källa: Entry Practice Schedule, part T, issue 1

    In a record, every closure entry must say where the original papers behind it are stored. Each closure entry owes this whatever its matter, without first mentioning papers at all. The duty rests on the author of the record.

Regler dokumentet redan uppfyller

  • Regel A

    Uppfylls av det här textstället

    The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.

Facit

Skrevs ner innan motorn kördes. papers-location-stated-truth

The same entry, saying where the papers are stored. The rule carries no crediting clause, so nothing is due either way.

Facit är uttömmande: varje fynd som inte står som förväntat räknas som fel.

Förväntade fynd

Inget fynd förväntas.

Varför inget ska rapporteras
Dokumentet uppfyller varje regel det fick. COMPLIANT

Förbjudna fynd

Fel svar, nedskrivna i förväg.

  • BristUtelämnandeFynd false-unstated-papers-location

    Reporting the papers' location as missing when the entry states it is a false positive, and an unlocated one is how this family's true target looks.

    Ska förankras i
    Förankras inte i något textställe, eftersom dokumentet aldrig nämner steget
    Ska hänvisa till
    Regel A
    Kontrolleras i
    granskarens eget utfall, den levererade rapporten

Vad den blinda läsaren svarade

En AI-läsare fick det här dokumentet och dess regler, men inte facit, och svarade på egen hand. Jämför svaret med facit ovan.

  • Överens med facitClaude, 23 september 2026Punkt i läsarens underlag item-17

    Läsaren rapporterade inget fynd.

    Regler som läsaren fann redan uppfyllda

    • Regel A: The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.

    Varför inget ska rapporteras Dokumentet uppfyller varje regel det fick. COMPLIANT

  • Överens med facitGemini, 4 oktober 2026Punkt i läsarens underlag item-04

    Läsaren rapporterade inget fynd.

    Regler som läsaren fann redan uppfyllda

    • Regel A: The original papers are stored in cabinet 12 of the east office.

    Varför inget ska rapporteras Dokumentet uppfyller varje regel det fick. COMPLIANT

Kritisk granskning av facit

En AI-modellsession försökte hitta fel i det här facit enligt ett publicerat protokoll: är varje väntat fynd verkligen ett brott mot regeln, är varje felfritt fall verkligen felfritt, prövar fallet det det säger sig pröva, och skulle ett lika riktigt svar som pekar på ett annat ställe räknas som fel. Den tittade inte på motorns resultat först. Varje invändning visas med hur den avgjordes. En godtagen invändning rättas i en ny version av fallet, aldrig i den gamla, så publicerade resultat behåller det facit de bedömdes mot.

Granskning av Claude, 4 oktober 2026

  • Invändning besvaradSvårighetRegel Ap3 · papers-location-presence

    Gäller hela gruppen av fall

    Rule A's second sentence tells the reader the duty is owed "without first mentioning papers at all", so it states the very property the family tests.

    Facit står kvar

    Unlike an exemption naming a case, the sentence states the rule's scope as a real rule would and does not settle either variant: whether the entry says where the papers are still decides the contrast.

Testets instruktion till granskaren

Testkonfigurationen gav AI-granskaren den här instruktionen vid sidan av reglerna. Det är testets egen instruktion. Produktionens systemprompt visas inte.

You read one document and apply only the rules supplied to you in the legal framework, exactly as each rule is written. Report every place where the document does not meet a supplied rule, and apply what a supplied rule says about how a record that meets it is to be recorded. Quote each passage exactly as it appears. Do not apply a rule that was not supplied, and do not rely on any knowledge of a legal system.

Vem som skrev och läste det här testfallet

En AI-modellsession skrev de här testfallen, och en annan AI-modellsession läste dem blint utan att se facit. Ingen människa har granskat dem.

Skrevs
, registrerat som Verkstaden implementer (Claude Local), #2323
Modellfamilj som skrev det
Claude
Varför det skrevs
Authored for #2323 as new REGRESSION material in the outcome shapes of the controlled-pilot suite, sharing none of its text. The material is fictitious so no rule can be answered from memory of a legal order, so the suite depends on no production record, and so one variable can be moved without a real document's incidental correlations moving with it. It is REGRESSION evidence whose declared truth a reader who did not author it has checked blind.

Granskning

Skrivna av en AI-modellsession: Claude.

  • Blind läsning, Claude, 23 september 2026: 22 av 22 överens

    registrerat som Verkstaden orchestrator session (Claude Opus 5.5), blind read

    Ingen oenighet med facit.

    Se vad den blinda läsaren svarade i varje testfall

  • Blind läsning, Gemini, 4 oktober 2026: 19 av 22 överens

    registrerat som gemini-2.5-pro (Vertex europe-west1), blind read

    3 oenigheter med facit

    • Punkt item-06

      The reader found the closure entry's missing statement of where its papers are stored, as declared, but placed it under the "Closing note" heading; the key places it under no section.

      Hur den avgjordes

      Genuinely ambiguous: the rule attaches the duty to the whole entry, but a closing note is a natural home for it, and the packet does not say which. Kept as declared; #3082 sharpens the case.

    • Punkt item-07

      The reader agreed nothing is due for the sample run from a tap, but gave the reason as a condition not triggered; the key declares the sample out of the rule's scope.

      Hur den avgjordes

      Genuinely ambiguous: the packet names the four reasons without defining them, and the rule's wording reads both as a scope limit and as an unmet condition. Kept as declared; #3083 sharpens the reasons.

    • Punkt item-17

      The reader found the levy charged from a figure with no named document, as declared, but quoted the sentence that sets the levy; the key anchors the flaw on the sentence that states the figure.

      Hur den avgjordes

      Reader wrong: the rule's duty attaches to the figure ("a figure whose document is not named"), and the packet anchors an unsupported claim on the claim itself, which here is the figure, not the charge set from it.

    Se vad den blinda läsaren svarade i varje testfall

  • Kritisk granskning, Claude, 4 oktober 2026: 0 invändningar

    registrerat som Claude Project thread session for #3049, adversarial critique

    Ingen oenighet med facit.

AI-modeller skrev och granskade de här testfallen, som anges ovan. Ingen människa har granskat dem. Varje oenighet mellan en AI-granskare och facit publiceras här.

Fingeravtryck

SHA-256-hashvärden som en läsare kan jämföra med en publicerad körnings rapport.

Dokument
2d2a5a773b541622b19e4da769ae33e2d6b79e5b2e3c75623bfa2c26768b3f2c
Dokumentmall
8e8453d2c13349db47bc8a8625e3526784a24d3f3bd807ef19494c25263f6c55
Regel A
9179015ff26a2a0761ed1900dcb9a8b4361adb49cc61403b42fc4ab93235e471